So, the subject is subjectivity. The simplest way to understand subjectivity is as an opinion or truth-claim based solely upon personal experience and/or preference. A good example in which everyone carries some subjectivity is musical tastes. I don’t believe anybody would seriously claim to have the authority on what music superior or inferior to others, at least not based solely on stylistic varieties. People generally respect the musical tastes of others, and the musical world is better for it.
Here is where things get sticky. When subjectivity is superimposed on issues of truth and falsehood, and right and wrong, morality and all knowledge cease to exist. Let me give an example of how subjectivity has overtaken American culture, and what harm it has done.
I know I may get railed for this, so let me clarify–I do not watch the show “The Bachelor” on a consistent basis, or ever, for that matter. HOWEVER, one of my roomates turned it on the other night, because it was the season finale. And I must say, I was hooked from the start due to the obvious ridiculousness of the show. Though it was pretty obvious that the context of the drama was a hollywood set-up, the star of the show set himself up for absolute disaster. The guy, named Jason, had to pick between two women from which to propose. After much emotional confliction, he decided to propose to the girl named Melissa. Six months down the road, he claims he has realized he had made the wrong decision in deciding on Melissa, and that he REALLY should have picked Molly, the other girl. Again, let’s try to put the ridiculousness aside of picking a wife in six weeks on a TV show. Even still, Jason says that although he hates to break Melissa’s heart, he has no choice but to “follow his heart”. He wants to live “with no regrets” and be “true to himself”. If the consequences are breaking the heart of a woman six months after proposing to her, tough luck.
Here’s where a hilarious TV moment becomes a serious dilemma. We all realize how ridiculous the event on the Bachelor is, but do we not realize that this happens every day within the context of marriage? One of the leading causes of divorce is that one spouse is no longer fulfilled with the other. The solution: drop all the baggage and follow your heart. Again, personal gain and selfish desire are king, and the hearts of undeserving spouses are kicked to the curb.
How about this–A man says, “I have an uncontrollable desire to brutally murder the next individual I come into contact with. I really can’t help that I have the desire, and to refuse consenting to my ‘need’ would be wrong. I want to live with no regrets, and if I don’t do this, I know I’ll regret it in the future. I mean, I hate that someone has to die, but I have to be true to myself.”
Sticky, sticky, sticky. Sorry America, but following your heart is overrated.
More on this to come….
